In this news Isabel Pantoja, a famous Spanish singer says that her daughter is pregnant and she requires that there be no publication about it claiming their right to privacy. She also says that some media have published information on Chabelita when she was a minor without respecting the child protection law.
I think that she was right in relation with the child protection because normally a minor can’t be appear in media without parental permission. But I disagree because it can not be violation of her privacy because she was showed her daughter since she was a child in different acts, concerts and others situations. So, like she has shown her privacy before she can’t required now their right to privacy.
Si te gustó el post, subscríbete a nuestro canal RSS
7 comments
MARTA MARIN OSTARIZ says:
Ene 13, 2014
In my opinion, this media haven’t violated the right to privacy of Chavelita. The pictures when she was a child have been published now, not when she was that age. Currently, Chavelita is a semi-public person, so her degree of protection depends on the projection that she has given itself or the projection that her mother, Isabel Pantoja, has given to her. If her mother has introduced her in several public events since she was a child, it is normal that her right to privacy is less than others.
Manuel Acero says:
Ene 16, 2014
In this case, there would be any kind of violation because he is a public person who has sold his privacy above. If it is true that the image of children may not appear in the media, but it is the daughter of a famous singer who has shown repeatedly, so now you can not try to protect children or the right to privacy, and your life before you sold it to the press.
Jorge Isla Villacampa says:
Ene 17, 2014
In my personal opinion, in this situation, although the mother has always published information about her children and showed them in public events, her daughter has right to privacy because it has been her mother who has published information but not Chabelita. Moreover, I think that because she is Pantoja daughter and is more exposed to the media she should be more protected in order not to prejudice her personal development, due to famous children are more vulnerable.
ADRIÁN SALVADOR says:
Ene 18, 2014
I think that in this case Chabelita, if that it could to take to the right of privacy or privacy, since it has been his mother, Isabel Pantoja who has showed in front of the media the image of his children. It is a fact noticiable because it is a person semi-public and this carries to the interest of the rest of people. Therefore, I think that Primary the right to the privacy since it has not been she the one who have said that was pregnant but his mother to be able to take out money of the scoop.
Ignacio Garralaga says:
Ene 19, 2014
I think that in this case does not violate the privacy of the child. Although it is a minor and if this limit above all and it should be respected, as the daughter of an famous that their own mother cannot require that right , now he has been who previously has profited from self-image of their daughter. In this case the penalty shouldn’t be for the press, because she has vulnerate the image of her daughter from the beginning. As previously said, if the artist had remained her daughter in anonymity if you could avail them to the accusation, but using his daughter as a tool to get benefit through the press, must now take responsibility for it. By the press may be required in this case the right to information.
Álvaro Antoñanzas says:
Ene 19, 2014
This is a common situation that often happens with celebrities, most of the cases, those who have sold their private life in the past, have sold their right to privacy too, so there wouldn’t be any doubt. But in this particular case, the affected person is not Isabel Pantoja but her daughter. There is no doubt that Chabelita still own her right to privacy and she would be in her right, suing any media that invades her privacy. She is not a semi-public person, so no one has the right to invade her private life. In the case of Isabel Pantoja, it’s obvious that the press is going to chase her to ask about her daughter pregnancy, and this would not be considered a right violation. What happens when Chabelita is with her mother? Well, in my opinion, the press should not try to get photos or any other type of information of Chabelita’s privacy; the right of privacy of chavelita is above the fact that her mother had always sold her life.
Ángel Boira says:
Ene 22, 2014
I think the media has not violated the right to privacy of the daughter of Isabel Pantoja, since both are public figures, they receive a great life and money thanks to fame.
Chavelita photographs have been published now that she is older and a public figure known throughout the country for being Pantoja´s daughter, a fact which she has used to their advantage in the past and present.